Derpy Hooves Poll

Calling all bronies. This is an experiment I would love to have all of you join in. Here are two posters of Derpy Hooves. Both are in reference to the first time she was made canon, the first time she had a significant line, and the subsequent stripping of this beautiful acknowledgement to bronydom. I would like to know your thoughts on both posters. Which one do you like more? Do you understand both of them? If not, which one is easier to understand? If you wanted to buy one of them, which one would you buy? Why? I know I have a lot of questions but if you could just take a few minutes to answer them, it would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you all so much for your feedback. I really appreciate it. This is dinopants174 and this is one of my first completed pieces. I have a clean and true-to-style take on my fanart and I hope you like them. I will upload whichever one seems to be more popular as a final.